Making History: The Storytellers Who Shaped the Past

Making History: The Storytellers Who Shaped the Past

  • Downloads:4576
  • Type:Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
  • Create Date:2022-04-16 17:21:42
  • Update Date:2025-09-06
  • Status:finish
  • Author:Richard Cohen
  • ISBN:B098BNSLBP
  • Environment:PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle

Summary

A fascinating, epic exploration of who gets to record the world’s history—from Julius Caesar to William Shakespeare to Ken Burns—and how their biases influence our understanding about the past。

There are many stories we can spin about previous ages, but which accounts get told? And by whom? Is there even such a thing as “objective” history? In this lively and thought-provoking book, Richard Cohen reveals how professional historians and other equally significant witnesses, such as the writers of the Bible, novelists, and political propagandists, influence what becomes the accepted record。 Cohen argues, for example, that some historians are practitioners of “Bad History” and twist reality to glorify themselves or their country。

The History Makers investigates the published works and private utterances of our greatest chroniclers to discover the agendas that informed their—and our—views of the world。 From the origins of history writing, when such an activity itself seemed revolutionary, through to television and the digital age, Cohen brings captivating figures to vivid light from Thucydides and Tacitus to Voltaire and Gibbon, Winston Churchill and Henry Louis Gates。 Rich in complex truths and surprising anecdotes, the result is a revealing exploration of both the aims and art of history-making, one that will lead us to rethink how we learn about our past and about ourselves。

Download

Reviews

Donna Holland

A brilliantly researched book about Making History 。Covers such a broad expanse of topics from the origins of history writing through to the television age 。One of the best non fiction reads I’ve absorbed - scholarly yet engaging and fun 。

Pickle。

4。75*

Michael Reilly

This is a history of writing history。 It is difficult to write an entertaining and reliable history of writing history。 Many of these types of books descend into the pits of theory。 It becomes easy to forget that individual, peculiar, fallible humans are responsible for writing history, not abstract theories。 Another risk is that we get a catalog of historians arranged chronologically without a sense of the big sweep of history and the connections between historians across time。 Richard Cohen do This is a history of writing history。 It is difficult to write an entertaining and reliable history of writing history。 Many of these types of books descend into the pits of theory。 It becomes easy to forget that individual, peculiar, fallible humans are responsible for writing history, not abstract theories。 Another risk is that we get a catalog of historians arranged chronologically without a sense of the big sweep of history and the connections between historians across time。 Richard Cohen does an excellent job of avoiding both pitfalls。 He does not have a grand overarching theory of history and he is fascinated by the individuals who did it。 At the same time, he is very good at drawing connections and comparisons。He starts, as you must, with Herodotus and Thucydides。 He travels fairly quickly。 It takes him 80 of the books 660 pages to get through the Greeks and the Romans。 The chapters of the book are roughly chronological。 He stops to explore。 We get a chapter on historians wrestling with the Bible from 200 AD to the present。 The chapter on Muslim history argues that history served a different purpose in the Muslim world than it did in the Western world。The second half of the book is chapters dealing with modern historical issues and controversies。 Cohen has a wonderful dual profile of Hugh Trevor-Roper and A。 J。 P。 Taylor。 They were two of best-known English historians of the 50s and 60s。 They were both public intellectuals。 They couldn't stand each other。 Trevor-Roper eventually was humiliated when he authenticated the fake Hitler diaries。 Cohen tells the story of the team which allowed Winston Churchill to "write" his best-selling histories。 His chapter on historians who overcame physical limitations features John Keegan。 Keegan's book, "The Face of Battle" is one my favorite military histories。 I have reread it several times。 I did not know that Keegan suffered his entire life from a crippling back issue。 He ended up almost doubled over but he continued to write brilliant history。The chapter on the American Civil War seemed a bit cursory, perhaps because it is a field I know pretty well。 There are chapters on woman historians and black historians。 He has an interesting section on Ken Burns and TV history in general。 He discusses the use of history in Shakespeare and in novels。 He reviews Marxist history。 Cohen is an entertaining writer。 He writes in a personal tone and has an eye for interesting and significant details。 "In Churchill's own estimate, he consumed half a bottle of champagne a day for forty-eight years", which was, of course, in addition to the copious wine, cognac, brandy and other liquor he drank every day。 This is a non-academic survey of the people who wrote history, but it is packed with intelligent discussions of how it was done over the last 2500 years。 。。。more